Expense Ratios: A Guaranteed Way to Control Your Returns
As a dad planning for both retirement and your children's future education, you're likely investing in a mix of accounts: 401(k)s, IRAs, and maybe even 529 college savings plans. While choosing good investments is crucial, there's a less obvious factor that can significantly impact your family's long-term wealth: expense ratios.
An expense ratio is the annual fee that funds charge their shareholders. It might seem small—often less than 1%—but over decades, these fees can eat away at your returns in a way is hard to understand... until now.
We've created this interactive simulation to show you exactly how much of a difference these seemingly tiny fees can make over time. Try adjusting the expense ratios, timelines, and investment amounts below to match your situation and see the impact for yourself.
Expense Ratio Impact Simulator
Adjust Your Scenario
A Note on Expense Ratio Values
The default values chosen aren't random. As of Feb 2025, the low-cost ratio (0.03%) represents what you might pay for a broad market ETF like VOO which tracks against the S&P 500. The higher ratio at 3x (0.09%) is for SPY, a fund run by SPDR State Street Global Advisors, which also tracks against the S&P 500.
It's also worth calling out that Vanguard just announced yesterday it's largest reduction of expense ratios to date. To see if there are savings to be had in your portfolio you can see the full list of reduced funds here.
How the Calculation Works
This model simulates investment growth using daily compounding while factoring in expense ratios. Returns are applied daily based on an annual expected return, and fees are deducted daily to reflect real-world fund management costs. Monthly contributions are added approximately every 30 days. This approach provides a more accurate projection compared to simpler monthly models.
What Kinds of Opportunities Does This Create?
The difference in final amounts represents real opportunities for your family. That could mean:
- A more secure retirement
- Additional college education funds for your children
- A larger inheritance for your family
- More financial flexibility during your working years
The good news is that finding low-cost funds is easier than ever. Most major brokerages offer index funds with expense ratios under 0.1%. Even many 529 college savings plans now offer low-cost index fund options.
Action Steps
Here's how to check and optimize your investment fees:
- Review Your Current Investments: Log into your accounts and look up the expense ratios for each fund you own. For 401(k)s, this information should be in your plan documents.
- Compare Available Options: Most 401(k)s and 529 plans offer at least one low-cost index fund option. Look for funds with "index" in their name or expense ratios under 0.2%.
- Make a Plan to Switch: If you find you're in high-cost funds, plan to transition to lower-cost alternatives. For taxable accounts, consider tax implications before selling.
- Stay the Course: Once you've selected low-cost funds, resist the urge to chase performance or switch to actively managed funds. The math of low costs tends to work in your favor over time.
Common Questions
"Don't higher fees mean better performance?"
Actually, research consistently shows that lower-cost funds tend to outperform their higher-cost peers over long periods. This is because the fee advantage compounds over time, just like your returns.
"What about actively managed funds?"
While some actively managed funds do outperform, it's extremely difficult to identify these winners in advance. The higher fees create a significant hurdle that most active funds fail to overcome consistently.
"Should I move all my money to low-cost funds immediately?"
If you're investing in taxable accounts, consider tax implications before making changes. For retirement accounts like 401(k)s and IRAs, you can usually switch funds without tax consequences.
Get our best tips and advice delivered once a month — quick reads, practical takeaways, no fluff.